Best Trout Lures
Five trout lures the experts keep picking for rivers, streams and lakes, from the Blue Fox Vibrax to Jeff's Mepps Aglia, with how many of six sources name each.
The short answer
The Blue Fox Classic Vibrax is the trout lure the experts name most, appearing in all 6 sources we read. Rapala minnows, the Leland's Trout Magnet, the Acme Little Cleo and the Mepps Aglia round out the list. Only the Mepps is a lure Jeff has fished himself.
Top picks at a glance
| Product | Sources | Type | Size to start | Status | Where to buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Named in 6 of 6 Blue Fox Classic Vibrax Spinner | 6 of 6 | Inline spinner | 7/64 or 1/8 oz | Consensus pick (not fished) | Check price (Classic Vibrax Spinner, affiliate link, opens in a new tab) |
| Rapala minnows in 5 of 6 Rapala Original Floating Minnow | 5 of 6 (Original Floating in 3) | Floating minnow plug | Small sizes (1.5 to 2.75 in) | Consensus pick (not fished) | Check price (Original Floating Minnow, affiliate link, opens in a new tab) |
| Named in 4 of 6 Leland's Lures Trout Magnet Neon Kit | 4 of 6 | Soft jig | 1/64 oz | Consensus pick (not fished) | Check price (Trout Magnet Neon Kit, affiliate link, opens in a new tab) |
| Named in 3 of 6 Acme Little Cleo Spoon (1/8 oz, Nickel) | 3 of 6 | Casting spoon | 1/8 oz | Consensus pick (not fished) | Check price (Little Cleo Spoon (1/8 oz, Nickel), affiliate link, opens in a new tab) |
| Named in 2 of 6, and fished by Jeff Mepps Aglia Spinner | 2 of 6 | Inline spinner | Size 0 or 1 | Consensus pick, fished by Jeff | Check price (Aglia Spinner, affiliate link, opens in a new tab) |
Blue Fox Classic Vibrax Spinner
Best for: Searching bigger water and stained or current-heavy stretches
The one lure every source names. It is heavy for its size, so it casts far, and the blade throws flash and a loud vibration. Several sources say it suits bigger water better than tiny clear streams. Consensus pick, not fished.
Pros
- Named in all 6 sources
- Casts far for its size
- Flash and vibration draw trout from a distance
Cons
- Sources say it can be too loud for small, clear streams
- Not fished by us; confirm the size on the Amazon page
Rapala Original Floating Minnow
Best for: Clear water, wary trout and imitating a baitfish
The classic black-over-silver style floating minnow. The Rapala family appears in five of the six sources, and the Original Floating itself in three. USAngler points out its quiet, lifelike action does not spook wary trout in clear water. The link goes to the silver version. Consensus pick, not fished.
Pros
- Rapala minnows named in 5 of 6 sources
- Quiet, lifelike action for clear water
- Small sizes for pan-sized trout, larger for big browns
Cons
- Not fished by us; confirm the size on the Amazon page
- Other Rapala models (Husky Jerk, CountDown) are named too
Leland's Lures Trout Magnet Neon Kit
Best for: Pressured trout and clear water on a light setup
A tiny split-tail worm body on a 1/64 oz jig head. Wired2Fish and FishUSA both name it their top soft plastic, and Outdoor Life calls it the best trout jig. It needs a light setup to cast. The link is the Neon kit. Consensus pick, not fished.
Pros
- Named in 4 of 6 sources
- Looks like a nymph, crayfish or small baitfish
- Works under a float or on the current
Cons
- Wired2Fish says it is hard to cast and needs a light setup
- The linked listing is the Neon kit, so check the colors
Acme Little Cleo Spoon (1/8 oz, Nickel)
Best for: Casting a long way into larger rivers, deep pools and lakes
The humpback casting spoon that wobbles like an injured baitfish. Wired2Fish names it the best metal trout lure and FishUSA its top spoon, and USAngler lists it too. The link is the 1/8 oz nickel. Consensus pick, not fished.
Pros
- Named in 3 of 6 sources
- Casts far and covers water in few casts
- Wobbles like a struggling baitfish
Cons
- Wired2Fish points it at larger rivers, lakes and deep pools
- Not fished by us; confirm the size on the Amazon page
Mepps Aglia Spinner
Best for: Streams and rivers, cast and retrieve at any speed
The inline spinner Jeff fished for years on New Hampshire streams, in size 0 or 1 with a gold or silver blade. Field & Stream and USAngler both name it, and Field & Stream says some trout anglers consider it the best trout lure ever made.
Pros
- Fished by Jeff in size 0 or 1
- Named by Field & Stream and USAngler
- Free-spinning blade works at any speed
Cons
- Named in only 2 of the 6 sources here, though it tops other lists
Trout lure lists are crowded, so this page counts. We read six published roundups and tallied which conventional lures show up most, then kept five that cover different jobs: a spinner, a minnow plug, a soft jig, a spoon and the Mepps Aglia that Jeff has fished himself. There are no fly-fishing picks here.
How this page was built
This is a consensus page, not a hands-on review. It tallies Wired2Fish, Outdoor Life, FishUSA, Field & Stream, USAngler and In-Fisherman. Sources are named, never quoted. Where Jeff has actually used a lure, the page says so with a field note, and every other pick is labeled consensus pick, not fished.
About the Amazon links: several go to a listing that covers many sizes and colors, and the Trout Magnet link is the Neon kit. Check the size and finish on the Amazon page before ordering.
Blue Fox Classic Vibrax: named in 6 of 6
Every source we read names the Vibrax: Wired2Fish, Outdoor Life, FishUSA, Field & Stream, USAngler and In-Fisherman. FishUSA picks it as its top trout spinner, and Outdoor Life lists it from 7/64 oz up to 5/8 oz, with silver, blue and white the most effective. Its heavy body casts far, and the blade gives off flash and a pulsing vibration. USAngler and Field & Stream both note it is better for big rivers, high or dirty water and lakes than for small clear streams, where it can be too loud. In-Fisherman suggests casting upstream and retrieving just fast enough to keep the blade turning. For more spinners, see the best trout spinners.
Check price on Amazon (affiliate link, opens in a new tab)Rapala Original Floating Minnow: Rapala minnows in 5 of 6
Rapala minnows turn up in five of the six sources, in three different models. The Original Floating Minnow is named by Field & Stream, USAngler and In-Fisherman, Outdoor Life picks the Husky Jerk for large rivers, and Wired2Fish picks the CountDown. USAngler lists the Original Floating in 1.5, 2 and 2.75 inch sizes and says its simple, lifelike action with no noise or flash avoids spooking wary trout in clear water. Field & Stream says small sizes work on pan-sized trout while the bigger ones can draw big browns. The Amazon link is the silver finish, so check the size on the page.
Check price on Amazon (affiliate link, opens in a new tab)Leland’s Trout Magnet: named in 4 of 6
Wired2Fish, Outdoor Life, Field & Stream and FishUSA all name the Trout Magnet. It is a 1/64 oz jig head with a small split-tail worm body, and the sources say it imitates nymphs, crayfish or small baitfish. Wired2Fish fishes it under a small float or lets the current carry it through pools and seams, and says it needs a light setup because it is hard to cast. Field & Stream says to let the current work the jig head instead of overworking it. FishUSA notes it works well on pressured trout in clear water. Outdoor Life favors black, white and subtle colors in clear water and pink or orange in muddy water. The Amazon link is the Neon kit.
Check price on Amazon (affiliate link, opens in a new tab)Acme Little Cleo: named in 3 of 6
Wired2Fish, FishUSA and USAngler name the Little Cleo. Its humpback shape wobbles like a struggling baitfish, it casts a long way and it resists spinning, according to USAngler. Wired2Fish says to use a steady retrieve, or crank a few times and pause so it flutters, and notes it suits larger rivers, lakes and deep pools. USAngler lists 1/16, 1/8 and 1/4 oz sizes and points to river mouths and deep stream pools for bigger trout. FishUSA suggests casting upstream and letting it flutter down with the current. The link is the 1/8 oz nickel.
Check price on Amazon (affiliate link, opens in a new tab)Mepps Aglia: named in 2 of 6, and fished by Jeff
Field & Stream and USAngler both name the Aglia. Field & Stream says that to a lot of trout anglers it is among the best trout lures ever made, with or without the squirrel-tail dressing. USAngler lists sizes from #0 (1/12 oz) to #3 (1/4 oz) in silver, copper, gold and hot orange, and says its free-spinning brass blade works at any speed. Field note (Jeff): this is the spinner he fished for years on New Hampshire streams, in size 0 or 1 with a gold or silver blade, on a 6 foot 6 inch spinning rod and 6 to 8 pound mono. His full setup is in his trout rod picks for New Hampshire rivers and streams.
Check price on Amazon (affiliate link, opens in a new tab)Also named, not linked
Worden’s Rooster Tail, Panther Martin and the Acme Phoebe spoon each appear in 3 of the 6 sources, and the Kastmaster and Flatfish are also named. The two spinners are on the best trout spinners page. Berkley PowerBait trout bait and the Floating Trout Worm appear in 5 of the 6 sources, mostly for stocked trout, but it is a scented bait more than a lure, so it is not on this list.
How to choose
- Match the lure to the water. Quiet, small lures like the Rapala floater or the Trout Magnet suit small, clear streams. The Vibrax and the Little Cleo suit bigger or higher water.
- Match the color to the clarity. FishUSA suggests natural, silver or gold in clear water and bright, flashy colors in stained water.
- Keep the lure light. FishUSA suggests 1/16 to 1/4 oz for most stream spinners and spoons, on 4 to 6 lb line and a light or ultralight rod.
- Pick a line that fits. See the best trout fishing line, and the best trout rods for New Hampshire rivers and streams.
Counts come from six published sources. Only the Mepps Aglia reflects Jeff’s own use. Check size and finish on each Amazon page before ordering.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best trout lure?
By count, the Blue Fox Classic Vibrax, which all 6 sources we read name. Rapala minnows (5 of 6) and the Leland's Trout Magnet (4 of 6) follow.
What is the best trout lure for streams?
Jeff fished a Mepps Aglia in size 0 or 1 for years. The sources suggest small, quiet lures like the Rapala Original Floating or the Trout Magnet for small clear streams, and the Vibrax for bigger or higher water.
What size trout lure should I use?
FishUSA suggests 1/16 to 1/4 oz for most stream spinners and spoons, on 4 to 6 lb line and a light or ultralight rod.
What color trout lure should I use?
FishUSA suggests natural, silver or gold finishes in clear water and bright, flashy colors in stained water. Outdoor Life says similar for the Trout Magnet.
Is PowerBait a lure?
It is a scented soft bait. It appears in 5 of the 6 sources, mostly for stocked trout, but it is bait more than a lure, so it is not on this list.
Which of these lures does Jeff use?
The Mepps Aglia. The other four are consensus picks he has not fished.